This video consists of four parts. 2023 PRI Inc - All rights reserved. This was Owens third shooting during in his ten years of duty, and his employer, Prince Georges County Police Department hadnt ever done anything about his erratic and dangerous behavior, or the Police Departments Extensive History of Brutality, Racism, Poor Training and Supervision.
Jurors awarded $192,328 to the estate of Gregory Kafi Habib, who was 37 when he died after being beaten and stomped by police officers during a traffic stop. | Site Was Produced By Fsquaredmedia. I dont believe in reforming the system. Serious violations of civil rights in the public safety context can be committed by a range of individuals, including: Some of the more frequently occurring misconduct fact patterns for which victims may wish to seek compensation include the application of excessive physical force, use of undue restraints, unnecessary and degrading strip searches, sexual assault, blackmail or coercive tactics, racial profiling and illegal interrogations. PRINCE GEORGE'S COUNTY, Md. An experienced PG Countys police brutality lawyer could conduct a comprehensive investigation of the facts of each persons case, interviewing witnesses, and securing critical documentary evidence. And that, Victims seeking redress face daunting obstacles at every point in the process, ranging from overt intimidation to the reluctance of local and federal prosecutors to take on brutality cases of officers who have committed these human rights violations. EMC This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Authorities say an officer observed an assault and chased down a man who was handcuffed at the gas station. 1. EMC President Trump pardons former Prince George's County cop after 10 years in prison for police brutality At least 4 local police chiefs have resigned this year as nation grapples with systemic racism They dont know whos pregnant, whos sick or who just had surgery. /Tx BMC A Black man, William Green, was shot and killed by a police officer January 27, 2020. EMC In fact, Qiana Johnson, one of the co-organizers with Black Lives Matter D.C., can list incidents that occurred 20 years ago. This has even created an uneven and complex impact concerning the public health of, the country. The county denied the allegations in court filings, saying officers did not use excessive force and had probable cause to stop Rogers. KOFI L. BOATENG, et al. Iveys girlfriend was walking her dog when she spotted Rogers grabbing the handle of a neighbors vehicle, she said in court depositions. Prince Georges County, Maryland, is one of the wealthiest Black communities in America. endstream
endobj
77 0 obj
<>/Subtype/Form/Type/XObject>>stream
EMC 2 years later on MAY 1, 2019, KEVIN WAS ACQUITTED BY ALL 12 JURORS. Banning books is not a new phenomenon. In addition to that, we also have a Law Enforcement Officers Bill of Rights that only allows other sworn law enforcement officers to investigate an officer and only allows officers misconduct records that were unsustained be expunged after three years. /Tx BMC Forms of police brutality have ranged from assault and battery (e.g., beatings) to mayhem, torture, and murder. He has seen many innocent & hard-working people become VICTIMS of the Police Brutality. Prince George's County; DC; Crime News; Weather News; . Veterans effort to help woman becomes a police brutality case, Video Series: Off the Record with Sloane Brown, The Washington Post News Service & Syndicate, JOSEPH DANIEL PARRISH v. STATE OF MARYLAND, JOHN WESLEY LEE, JR. v. STATE OF MARYLAND. Prince George's County State's Attorney Aisha Braveboy discusses crime and other topics with FOX 5. . At least 950 instances of police brutality against civilians and journalists during anti-racism protests have occurred in the past five months, according to data collected by Bellingcat and . EMC Black Lawyers for Justice/Black Rights Matter, Malik Z. Shabazz, Esq. /Tx BMC /Tx BMC If you have suffered at the hands of a public safety official who overstepped the bounds of propriety, a Prince Georges County police brutality lawyer is the advocate you need, as they can effectively help you understand 1983 violations and what to do moving forward. Had the police department and had the community been able to have some oversight and transparency into these cases a decade ago and happily reprimanded him then, William Greens murder could have been 100 percent prevented.. /Tx BMC We have fruits from a poisonous tree. EMC I feel that any citizen attempting to assist a fellow citizen should not have to endure this type of harassment, mistreatment and degrading conduct, Rogers wrote, from those sworn to uphold the law.. The Clermont County, Ohio sheriff's office said an investigation suggests Steven Cain and two others were killed, and another . Through that case, we have found that there have been at least almost 7,000 use-of-force complaints in just the last four years, and 99.6 percent of those complaints were deemed justified by the police department, said Yanet Amanuel, a public policy advocate with the ACLU of Maryland. EMC endstream
endobj
63 0 obj
<>/Subtype/Form/Type/XObject>>stream
/Tx BMC Article. The topic of police misconduct has received heightened attention recently, due in large part to a series of highly-publicized incidents in Maryland as well as across the country. Related Articles. Activists, mothers and family members impacted by police brutality lobbied and testified to have state legislation passed. hb```"w6!FA30palx}qOH ?6 ];{eD;`W ;::$@1^K@#r0 Li? endstream
endobj
65 0 obj
<>/Subtype/Form/Type/XObject>>stream
1. We believe in order to do that, we have to first shift power over law enforcement into the hands of the community by ending the police policing themselves. Robert Edwards and Cpl. As Rogers fished for her trapped keys with a coat hanger, a man with a gun at his side appeared. The five demands include repealing the Law Enforcement Officers Bill of Rights, revising the Maryland Public Information Act to make police internal investigation records and misconduct records transparent, placing statutory limits on police use-of-force, removing police from schools and giving the county control over its own police department. endstream
endobj
49 0 obj
<>/Subtype/Form/Type/XObject>>stream
Were concerned about what's going on in our community.. We are involved citizens, said Dorothy Elliott, whose son was killed by police. %PDF-1.6
%
/Tx BMC endstream
endobj
57 0 obj
<>/Subtype/Form/Type/XObject>>stream
28 Jobs. She also explains how there's an immediate need for body-worn cameras on every officer in Prince George's County Maryland in order to keep the citizens safe. I say shut it down and lets get those things and be done with the system of policing.. endstream
endobj
startxref
College Park Fraternity/Sorority Life and Title IX, Common Sense Bike Safety and Laws along the I-95, Concurrent College Park Criminal Investigations and Title IX, Catastrophic Injuries From Dangerous Animals, Expert Witnesses in DC Catastrophic Injury Cases, Initial Consultation in DC Catastrophic Injury Cases, Receiving Payment Following a DC Catastrophic Injury Claim, Washington DC Lumbar Spinal Cord Injuries, Alternative Dispute Resolution Methods in DC Civil Litigation Cases, Benefits of a DC Civil Litigation Attorney, Contract Dispute Negotiation in DC Civil Litigation Cases, Requirements for Filing a Contract Dispute in DC, Contributory Negligence in DC Dog Bite Cases, Contributory Negligence in Dog Bite Cases, Establishing Liability in DC Dog Bite Cases, Contacting Insurance After an Accident in DC, Defining Prima Facie in DC Nursing Home Abuse Cases, Dehydration in Washington DC Nursing Homes, Establishing Liability in DC Nursing Home Abuse Cases, Expert Witnesses in DC Nursing Home Abuse Cases, Expert Witnesses in DC Nursing Home Abuse Trials, Injury Claims in DC for Undocumented Immigrants, Requesting A Police Report After An Accident in DC, Settlements in Washington DC Personal Injury Cases, Statute of Limitations in DC Nursing Home Abuse Cases, Washington DC Jewish Personal Injury Lawyer, DC Commercial Property Premises Liability Lawyer, DC Private Property Premises Liability Lawyer, DC Toxic Chemicals and Material Liability Lawyer, What Makes a Strong DC Premises Liability Case, A DC Spinal Cord Injury Lawyers Responsibilities, DC Spinal Cord Injury Cases: Assessing Damages, Establishing Liability in DC Spinal Cord Injury Cases, Home Modifications After a Spinal Cord Injury in Washington DC, Our Approach to DC Spinal Cord Injury Cases, Sacral Spinal Cord Injuries in Washington DC, Spinal Cord Injury Rehabilitation and Alternative Therapies in Washington DC, Thoracic Spinal Cord Injuries in Washington DC, Statute of Limitations and Residency in DC Personal Injury Cases, DC Veterans Affairs (VA) Medical Centers, Abogado de Crmenes Federales en Washington DC, Expert Witnesses in a DC Personal Injury Cases, Expert Witnesses in DC Personal Injury Cases, Gathering Evidence in a DC Breach of Fiduciary Duty Claim, Determining the Validity of a Workers Compensation Claim in Glen Burnie, Mistakes to Avoid When Making a Glen Burnie Workers Compensation Claim. The police department investigated internally and found no wrongdoing, the court file shows. A Team of 40 Experienced and Knowledgeable Attorneys Ready to Fight For You, Prince Georges County Personal Injury Attorney. The police of Prince George had shot or killed, more individuals of the County per every officer that any other of the 50 county law enforcement, agencies and cities that are largest in the country having almost 85% of them being black. This was not Prince Georges County first run-in with police brutality. Our nation practices a selective blindness. She also commented on how police in schools contribute to the school-to-prison pipeline. v. KRISTINE D. BROWN, et al. "That was the final nail in the coffin.". According to eyewitnesses, Owen then got out of the police cruiser visibly nervous and in a panic, the statement reads. Ivey said he asked Rogers where he lived, the officer said in court depositions, but was met with the questions, Who are you? and Where do you live?. We have problems with our voting. The incident began when police Cpl. "It's Prince George's County. Our team of attorneys at Price Benowitz are always ready and willing to provide knowledgeable legal counsel to those in need. For this reason, it is often possible for those subjected to such treatment to receive substantial financial compensation as well as a sense of vindication from the courts.
The victims include African Americans, the mentally challenged, and immigrant populations, creating a. After settling the Green case, on September 28, 2020, for $20 Million dollars, his firm filed another lawsuit in December of 2021, a federal civil rights mass action against Prince Georges County on behalf of these (7) victims, In this Special edition of Justice in America, our news team sits down with Billy, and his guests, to discuss this latest lawsuit and what it means for the Prince Georges County police dept and citizens. It says his behavior demonstrates a "consistent and well-known history of police brutality." "For 50 plus years, Prince George's County has condoned the brutality inflicted by its police . EMC Rogers said yes and asked the same of the stranger, who didnt answer, according to his letter.
Steven Kerpelman stopped the Habib brothers while they were. The Army veteran was taking a morning walk on doctors orders when he came upon a woman locked out of her car. She said the ACLU has been working with a coalition of 85 organizations to push five demands to address all the ways in which policing in Maryland is terrorizing Black and Brown communities. Michael W. Kirk, the lawyer for Martin Habib, said his client suffered a broken jaw and bruises in addition to post-traumatic stress disorder from watching his brother die on the street beside him. Out of, the over 145 citizens that were shot and killed between the 1990s, about 12 of them were. I say shut it down and get homeless shelters, get addiction centers, get reentry centers mental health and also clinics, she said.
And the reason why I feel like that is because he was rewarded for his bad behavior. /Tx BMC EMC I didnt see any reason for him to complain against me for anything, Ivey said in his deposition. Owen shot William from point blank range seven times, striking him six times in the torso. He understands that Police brutality is one of the most serious, enduring, and divisive human rights violations in the United States. Through her work in the community, she found out that her high school teacher, Dorothy Elliott, had a son who was shot and killed by police 20 years ago. Towers, Hyattsville Police, Maryland State Police, and Other local Municipal Police Departments. /Tx BMC /Tx BMC The officers girlfriend never observed Ivey forcibly grab or push Plaintiff down on the curb and Rogers did not appear to be in pain while seated on the curb, the county said in court filings. Police brutality and misconduct cases can and regularly do implicate a range of state statutes and federal laws. BECAUSE INJUSTICE ANYWHERE IS A THREAT TO JUSTICE EVERYWHERE !!! Mr. Gilbreath was not in court yesterday. They proceeded to take him out of his car, searched him and arrested him. On Wednesday, the president pardoned former Prince George's County police K-9 officer Stephanie Mohr. The jury yesterday found that all four officers violated civil rights by using excessive force against Gregory Habib. How a Prince George's County Police Brutality Attorney Can Protect Your Right There can be no denying that when a law enforcement officer engages in misconduct or acts of unwarranted physical brutality, the detrimental effects on the victim as well as the broader community are profound. endstream
endobj
72 0 obj
<>/Subtype/Form/Type/XObject>>stream
endstream
endobj
84 0 obj
<>/Subtype/Form/Type/XObject>>stream
A man was shot and killed Friday night in Prince George's County, Md., the county police said. Michael Nwaulu, 17, of Upper Marlboro, was identified as the victim in the shooting . UPPER MARLBORO, Md. /Tx BMC Prince George's County Police have suspended two officers and their supervisor after cell phone video was posted online showing one of the officers kicking a man while handcuffing him at a gas station in Langley Park, officials announced Tuesday. A Prince George's grand jury heard evidence in the case in 1989 but did not bring criminal charges against the officers. As a user, if you see something we have missed, please do bring it to our attention. Corporal Kerpelman and the other officers, Cpl. EMC Teen shot and killed in Upper Marlboro, Maryland; another teen . More than 1,400 police officers and 300 civilians provide a full range of law enforcement services to nearly 900,000 residents and business owners. The deadly shooting occurred Monday night during an apparent struggle inside the cruiser after Prince George's County police officers responded to reports that a driver had struck. EMC high court says sex abuse law applies to substitute teacher. /Tx BMC The excessive use of force by police officers, including unjustified shootings, severe beatings, and fatal chokings persists. In October 2019, a 24-year-old man was partially paralyzed in a police encounter. Not fixing the policing issues in our community is not only costing Black people their lives in the streets, its also taking them in the courts, because we have wrongful convictions due to an officer lying in a statement, she said. Weve had problems with our census. Quickly, the attempt to be a good Samaritan became a case of police brutality, Rogers said in court filings, when the armed man turned out to be an off-duty Prince Georges County police officer who failed to properly identify himself as law enforcement and wrongfully grabbed Rogers. Police said the officer shot William Green of Washington, D.C. seven times while the man. endstream
endobj
67 0 obj
<>/Subtype/Form/Type/XObject>>stream
Fearing that a confrontation could aggravate his surgical wounds or worse, Rogers walked away.
A spokesperson with the county executives office released a statement, saying in part, The County Council has taken up the matter twice Those meetings are open for live viewing online and can be watched online after the fact. After police arrived Coppin jumped out of a first-story window and claimed to have a gun. The incident sparked controversy between the police department and Prince George's County blacks, who said the case showed that county police were brutal toward blacks. endstream
endobj
75 0 obj
<>/Subtype/Form/Type/XObject>>stream
The legislation is also available for review online,and there will be opportunity for public discussion during a public hearing that must be held as part of the legislative process. "The case is about two illegal aliens who did not want to be arrested by police officers." Steven Kerpelman stopped the Habib brothers while they were riding through Langley Park in their red Toyota just after 3 p.m. on May 20, 1989. LANGLEY PARK, Md. Some counties have held public meetings allowing the community to weigh in throughout the process. "Obviously, we're pleased," Mr. Kirk said of the verdict. /Tx BMC In essence, this statute prohibits anyone acting under the color of state law from violating a citizens fundamental constitutional rights. The officer then forced Rogers to sit on a curb until more police arrived, although Rogers told him that sitting would further rip the device just implanted in his body. What Should You Expect in Your First Case? %%EOF
Editorial Guidelines It was at that point that he started to walk and go right in my face, Rogers wrote. Is Israel baiting the U.S. into war with Iran? The Prince George's County police officer who killed William Green in January was arrested on charges including second-degree murder and has a trial scheduled for next year. (7News) Suspended Prince George's County Police Department Cpl. Americans were the majority in the late 1980s, and in 1994, they elected a black, Hutto & Green, 2016). Ivey, when reached through the local police union, did not respond to a request for comment. Martnez travels to Nicaraguan fishing towns, southern Mexican brothels where Central American women are trafficked, isolated Guatemalan jungle villages, and crime-ridden Salvadoran slums. 167 0 obj
<>stream
1983. He was involved in a fatal shooting in 2011, and he was also collecting workers compensation after a bunch of these instances.
EMC In July, eight years after the encounter that damaged a delicate medical device implanted in Rogers back, a Prince Georges jury found the Maryland county, just outside the District of Columbia, liable for $850,000 in damages. Two of Mr. Greens children, a son and a daughter, his mother and others stood by the familys lawyer at a Sept. 28 press conference announcing a $20 million settlement. According to his own testimony, he basically cornered Prince's car pulled out a gun--but no badge--and IDed himself as an officer.. Officer (Corporal Windsor) who turned off his cruiser camera before exit. Michael Owen. Attorneys in Prince George's County continue to spar over whether an expert report outlining alleged officer misconduct and systemic racial discrimination within the police department should be . "I am sharing the video in the interest of transparency. A few months ago in June 2020, a video showed three officers beating a man in an effort to detain him. He goes undercover to drink with narcos, accompanies police . We do not allow opaque clients, and our editors try to be careful about weeding out false and misleading content. /Tx BMC EMC A Maryland jury has awarded a Greenbelt woman a $261,000 Prince George's County police brutality verdict. "While he's in the street, he sees these two men coming at him. EMC endstream
endobj
55 0 obj
<>/Subtype/Form/Type/XObject>>stream
The tree is poisonous, and the fruit that it bears, all of them are poisonous, she continued. Unfortunately, the trauma of Black people period, historically, has led us to believe that we have to bootstrap and be a part of capitalism and we have to hide things and pretend as though things are not happening in order to protect our image, Ms. Johnson said. EMC #Breaking: Prince George's County Police officer Bryant Strong is found guilty of 2nd degree assault, reckless endangerment and misconduct in office.It stems from a 2019 traffic stop that left . endstream
endobj
81 0 obj
<>/Subtype/Form/Type/XObject>>stream
He wants to go home.
A shooting in Prince George's County, Maryland, left one teenager dead and another injured Thursday night. /Tx BMC endstream
endobj
50 0 obj
<>/Subtype/Form/Type/XObject>>stream
If Rogers had then refused the orders, the officer might have been allowed to lay a hand on Rogers, Hansel said. '(The Daily Record/Maximilian Franz). If you or someone you love has been mistreated by a public safety officer, and you wish to learn more about your options, a Prince Georges County police brutality lawyer is ready to assist. https://youtube.com/watch?v=2Tspf8OsL1w&feature=share. Racist police brutality has been systemic in Prince George's County, Maryland. People impacted by police brutality and activists rallied outside the county executives office Thursday to bring attention to their concerns about the creation of the police accountability board and the legislation overseeing it. And because of that, he is driven to fight for people who had been harmed by the willful or negligent actions of others. /Tx BMC Racist police brutality has been systemic in Prince George's County, Maryland.
Lawyers for Prince George's County who defended the officers said they would appeal the verdict. /Tx BMC Population of Prince George's County 62% 17% 13% Prince George's County Police Dept Demographics 42% 9% 45% People Arrested 83% 12% People Killed 94% 6% Source: Uniform Crime Report , Mapping Police Violence , LEMAS Police Accountability i Section Score: 30% Total civilian complaints N/A from | N/A Ruled in Favor of Civilians No Data Found Add Data One of the officers, Corporal Michael Owen Jr., who was with the police department for 10 years, put Mr. Green in the front passenger seat of his police cruiser. Jomo Kenyatta University of Agriculture and Technology, Nairobi, Forensic Psychology and Ethical Implications.docx, Size Comparisons | Infinite Cardinalities | Paradox and Infinity | edX.pdf, Overview Fine grained expression level rather than sentence or document level, 7 Library isbn on sociopolitical and cultural history Axis thus region the, Equity recognises that when one party to a contract is in a stronger position, 430 According to the Report form No 20 town hospital received information about, Limiting_Reactants-_criteria_A_formative.docx, Fox-Harrison,Microscope Lab Worksheet and Outline.docx, Question 20 Correct Mark 100 out of 100 Not flaggedFlag question Question text, 120 Guide to the Code of Ethics for Nurses with Interpretive Statements 2nd Ed, Audit Programme example Property 15m Sources of evidence for the existence of, Ch 19 Public Goods And Common Resources .pdf, Argument made in class regarding Tower of Babylon was that the Tower A was built. EIN Presswire's priority is source transparency. He urged the woman to go back in her house. In this great and strong nation, we have all become unwitting accomplices to the continuation of the conflict. Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. He was allowed and given the opportunity and the privilege to step down, in the face of all of this stuff that he allowed to go on under his leadership, she said. EMC Anyone who has ever been subjected to police misconduct or brutality can attest to the feelings of helplessness that arise as a result. One of . Stephanie Mohr sent her police dog after a suspect named Ricardo Mendez, resulting in Mendez's being severely bitten, the dog tearing out part of his lower leg. Racist police brutality has been systemic in Prince George's County, Maryland. You fast-forward it to the case of Mr. Green and you can see that nothing has changed but the administration.. /Tx BMC BUT to make sure ALL Americans have the right to a fair trial, honest cops, impartial prosecutors, and fair judges with NO AGENDAs. /Tx BMC William Green was pronounced dead shortly thereafter.. It was so real to me, because Im like, Hey, that was my high school teacher, she said. Police or public officials greet each new report of brutality with denials ..or explain that the act was just an aberration, while the administrative and criminal systems that should deter these abuses by holding officers accountable instead, virtually guarantee them impunity. Jurors awarded $1.7 million in compensatory and punitive damages to Martin Akin Habib, a Ghanaian national who is now 34. As counties across Maryland create state-mandated police accountability boards, questions remain about the process in Prince George's County. County," said Howard Stone, a county resident of more than 42 years and the county council's committee director. Lynh Bui
During my tenure as Chief of Police, four officers have been criminally prosecuted for assault. Since the 1990s, Prince George's has been the wealthiest majority-black county in the country; today, its median household income is about $74,000 annually, and it is chock-full of lawyers,. Poor judgment, uncontrolled anger and blatant disregard for established policies and protocols on the part of some can yield severe injuries, emotional harm and in extreme cases, fatalities. County attorneys said police momentarily detained Rogers before he was released because his behavior appeared suspicious and a call had been received for a person attempting to break into a vehicle.. The horrific images of Rodney King being beat by the LAPD is one of the most blatant reminders of police brutality against innocent victims. These cookies do not store any personal information.
But it generally is well-known that a plaintiff who survives will have greater damages.". EMC EMC endstream
endobj
86 0 obj
<>/Subtype/Form/Type/XObject>>stream
Michael Owen, had a history of use-of-force complaints. Owen got into the drivers seat and several minutes later, gunshots rang out. According to a statement by the law firm retained by Mr. Greens family, he was driving his car when he accidentally hit three parked cars. If it can happen to him, it can happen to any of us.. endstream
endobj
87 0 obj
<>/Subtype/Form/Type/XObject>>stream
The cop was in an unmarked car, and wasn't wearing a uniform. Subscribers to The Daily Record can access the digital edition archive. EMC endstream
endobj
66 0 obj
<>/Subtype/Form/Type/XObject>>stream
There has been a history of policing issues in the county, but we know that policing issues started from the inception, because its rooted in White supremacy and originated from White people being recruited to track down and kill enslaved people, she said. Family members of people killed or injured by police in the county presented a list of demands for immediate change and rejected County Executive Angela Alsobrooks' chosen approach for reform. Racist police brutality has been systemic in Prince George's County, Maryland. It takes a pretty severe jerking to cause this kind of damage, said Hansel, adding that a medical expert from Walter Reed testified to that information during trial. As protests against police brutality continued across the Washington region on Saturday, demonstrators in Prince George's County voiced their concerns about the county police. The police chief has stepped down, which I think is a whole bunch of baloney. The horrific images of Rodney King being beat by the LAPD is one of the most blatant reminders of police brutality against innocent victims. My first instinct told me he was going to attempt to rob us, Rogers wrote in his letter. tries to define some of the boundaries that are reasonable in today's world. EMC endstream
endobj
68 0 obj
<>/Subtype/Form/Type/XObject>>stream
He noted that an autopsy showed that Gregory Habib had a trace of marijuana in his system. The panel ruled that the officers violated the brothers' civil rights. All rights reserved, Tracee Wilkins, News4 Investigative Reporter, Eagles Wide Receiver Zach Pascal Robbed at Gunpoint in Maryland, Emergency Elections Meeting Held After College Park Mayor Arrest; Bond Hearing Monday, Driver Dies in Frederick, Maryland Tanker Fire; Northbound US Route 15 Lanes Closed, Family Explores Legal Action After Student Forced to Pick Cotton in Class. Her office says they've chosen members and are awaiting confirmation from the county council before releasing names. EMC - A jury late Friday found one of two police officers charged in the alleged beating of a University of Maryland student in 2010 guilty of second-degree assault, but cleared the second officer in. It is important to note that a large number of matters in this realm rely primarily on the safeguards contained in 42 U.S.C. And its nature is institutionalized. EMC You know all too well that that image that is being projected is a delusion, and you also know that every single county official will go to their grave first before they disrupt that title that we have been holding for so long, even though its not true..